Campare Similar Techs @page4

具備商業化較完整API相關技術的比較,該類型以吸引App廠商後續開發為主,才算有實際商業競爭力。

items CHi-D (mass product edition) Intel RealSense (SoftKinetic DS325 /F200) MS - Kinect 1/2
Theory
(IR)LED + CHi-D design
Laser + TOF sensor
Laser Speckles/ToF
Number of camera
x1 (only color sensor)
x2 or x3 (depth+color sensor)
x2 (depth+color sensor)
BOM cost

Low (only LED)

High

Very High

Fan

No

Unknown / No

Yes (constant temperature for Laser)
Power Consumption
0.1444 mW (According to the 2 major applications)
2’000 mW / 2’000 mW
13’200 mW / 2’500 mW
Default range
0.1m ~ 2m
0.15m ~1.0m / 0.2~3m
1.5m ~ 2.5m/0.5~4.5m
Dimension (min restriction)
16 x 6 mm (No restriction )
105 x 30 x 23 mm /150 x 30 x 58mm

(fixed distance of color & depth camera)

270 x 75 x 75 mm / 249 x 66 x 67mm

(fixed distance of color & depth camera)

Computing cost for depth map
Low
Low
High
BOM cost (by USD)
1/3 of the cost
(during non-MP/samples)
$70-80 (2nd. Gen.)
$150 (2nd. Gen.)